Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Air Traffic Control?

 The NY Times writer suggests that the current ATC system be scrapped. The writer notes:

This has been proved in program after failed program to upgrade air traffic control over the past 40 years. The Federal Aviation Administration continues to replace parts when it needs to rebuild a whole system that can match the demands represented by changes in air traffic volume and in the structure of air transportation. Just this month, the F.A.A. proudly announced that air traffic control will be free of floppy disks by 2028. Memo to the agency: It’s not the floppies that are the problem. It’s the system they are plugged into. Over the past 40 years, I estimate, tens of billions have already been spent on the same organizational and functional approach that has given us the rickety system that collapsed last week.

 Having worked on some of the projects in the early 70s at MIT, I fully agree. The FAA is notorious for is gross incompetence and failure to update. 

However it is not for lack of spending tons of money. MIT Lincoln Lab has been spending almost sixty years on ATC R&D.  Billions have been spent on allegedly the latest and greatest in ATC. Needless to say other have also benefited from money not well spent. 

The FAA will never be able to design such a system. It is the anathema of any Government project. The personnel lack the competence and qualities to make this happen. Just look at the head of the FAA, totally lacking in technical and operational expertise. The Head of DoT was a reality show star. Would you want them in the fox hole, not likely. 

So starting over is great but who is in charge, who is accountable, who is competent?